Why automation pricing is so confusing
There are four fundamentally different ways to pay for automation, and they have almost nothing in common. A $20/month Zapier plan sounds very different from a $5,000 build, but they might do the same thing — or they might not be comparable at all. The confusion comes from mixing up three separate costs:
- Tool/platform fees — what you pay for the software that runs the automation (Zapier, Make, n8n)
- Build cost — the time it takes to design, build, test, and document the workflow
- Maintenance cost — ongoing updates when an API changes, a tool updates, or your process evolves
Most pricing you see online only quotes one of these. A complete picture requires all three.
"The cheapest automation is rarely the least expensive. DIY Zapier costs $0 to start and $60,000/year in founder time if you're not careful."
The 4 ways to pay for automation in 2026
You sign up for a tool, follow tutorials, and build the workflows yourself. For simple automations (a contact form that creates a CRM record, a booking that sends a confirmation), this works fine.
- Tool costs: Zapier starts at $29.99/month, Make at $9/month
- Hidden cost: your time. Building a robust 3-step automation with error handling typically takes 4–12 hours if you're learning as you go
- Maintenance: integrations break when apps update. Budget 1–3 hours/month for fixes
- At volume (50K+ tasks/month), Zapier costs balloon to $600+/month
Best for: Very simple workflows. Founders who enjoy tinkering and have spare time. Businesses with 1–2 automations total.
Hire someone whose job is to build and maintain your automations — often a "RevOps analyst," "operations manager," or "systems administrator" depending on the business.
- Salary: $45,000–$85,000/year depending on market and seniority
- Payroll taxes: ~7.65% of salary = $3,400–$6,500/year
- Benefits (health, PTO, etc.): typically 25–35% of salary = $11,000–$30,000/year
- Recruiting: $3,000–$8,000 in job ads, time, and possibly a recruiter fee
- Ramp time: 60–90 days before they're productive
Best for: Large operations with 20+ automations to build and maintain. Businesses where automation is a core competency. Teams that need someone in-house for compliance or security reasons.
Hire an automation agency on a monthly retainer to build and maintain your workflows. Common in the enterprise space, increasingly popular with mid-market businesses.
- Retainer fees: typically $2,000–$10,000/month depending on agency size and scope
- Most agencies focus on enterprise clients — if you're a $2M/year service business, you'll often get junior staff
- Contract lock-in: 6–12 month minimums are common
- You often don't own the workflows in any meaningful way — they live on the agency's infrastructure
Best for: Businesses with complex, fast-changing automation needs that justify ongoing expert time. Enterprise organizations with IT/security requirements that require agency-grade compliance.
A specialist builds the automation for a fixed price, documents it, hands it over, and you own it outright. No monthly fees to the builder. No lock-in. The automation runs on your accounts.
- One-time build cost: $997–$7,500 depending on complexity
- You own the workflows on your own platform accounts
- Tool fees after delivery: typically $9–$99/month in Make or n8n costs
- Written documentation and Loom walkthrough included
- No ongoing retainer unless you want ongoing support
Best for: SMBs that want automation built right and don't want to pay forever. The 80% of service businesses with 3–8 core processes to automate and a clear scope.
Full cost comparison table
| Approach | Year 1 Cost | Year 2 Cost | You own it? | Time required |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| DIY Zapier (basic) | $360–$9,600 in fees + 50–200 hrs of your time | $360–$9,600/year ongoing | Sort of | High (ongoing) |
| In-house hire | $65,000–$100,000 all-in | $55,000–$90,000/year | Yes | Management only |
| Agency retainer | $24,000–$120,000/year | $24,000–$120,000/year | Rarely | Low |
| Fixed-price build | $997–$7,500 + $108–$1,200 tool fees | $108–$1,200/year (tool fees only) | Yes | Minimal |
What drives automation cost up
When we scope a build, these are the factors that increase the project cost:
- Number of tools integrated: Each integration requires mapping, testing, and error handling. A 2-tool automation is fundamentally simpler than a 7-tool automation.
- Branching logic complexity: "If the lead came from Facebook and the job value is over $5K, route to the senior sales rep — otherwise, go into the standard nurture sequence" = multiple conditional paths that need to be tested thoroughly.
- Data volume and transformation: High-volume businesses (1,000+ daily transactions) require more robust infrastructure, error handling, and sometimes dedicated hosting.
- Custom API work: If your software doesn't have a native integration, we build a custom API connection. This takes longer and costs more than using a pre-built connector.
- Undocumented processes: If you can't explain your workflow step by step, we have to spend discovery time mapping it before we can build it.
What drives automation cost down
- Clear, documented processes: If you can write out your workflow step by step, scoping is fast.
- Mainstream tools: Using HubSpot, QuickBooks, Stripe, Google Workspace — these all have reliable native integrations that reduce build time significantly.
- Focused scope: "Automate our lead follow-up sequence" is scoped and buildable. "Automate everything" is a discovery project.
- Stable volume: If your transaction volume is predictable, we can size the infrastructure correctly upfront.
The ROI math: a real example
This is based on a real HVAC client. The numbers have been generalized slightly, but the structure is typical.
The additional benefit the ROI box does not capture: automated review requests generated 34 new Google reviews in the first 90 days. Based on their average conversion from reviews to new customers, that translated to an estimated $8,000–$12,000 in additional revenue.
Industry stat: According to McKinsey's 2023 automation report, businesses that automate repetitive workflows see an average 20–35% reduction in process time and a 15–20% reduction in error rates on automated tasks.
The hidden cost of NOT automating
Not automating is not a free choice. Every week you run manual follow-up processes, you are paying for it in time. Here is where those costs hide:
- Staff time on repeatable tasks: If one person spends 10 hours/week on manual admin at $20/hr, that's $10,400/year in labor on work that could be automated for under $2,000.
- Human error costs: Missed follow-ups, data entered wrong, reminders that never went out. The average service business loses 2–4 customers per month to poor follow-up — at $500–$2,000 per customer lifetime value, that's $12,000–$96,000/year in preventable churn.
- Missed reviews: Without an automated review request, most businesses collect 1–3 reviews per month. Automated, they collect 15–40. Google reviews are the #1 local SEO signal — the gap compounds over time.
- Founder time cost: If you're doing the admin yourself, what's your hour worth? At $100/hr, 10 hours/week of avoidable work costs $52,000/year in opportunity cost.
"The question isn't whether you can afford to automate. It's whether you can afford the cost of not automating compounding for another 12 months."
What to ask any automation vendor before signing
- Q1 Do I own the workflows when you're done? Some agencies build on their own infrastructure — if they disappear or you switch, you lose everything. Insist on delivery to your accounts.
- Q2 Is this a fixed price or hourly? Hourly quotes with "estimated" hours are open-ended. Insist on a fixed-price scope with clear deliverables.
- Q3 What's included if something breaks? API updates and tool changes happen. Is post-delivery support included? For how long?
- Q4 What are the ongoing tool costs? Get the actual monthly platform fees, not just the build cost. A $2,000 build on a $500/month Zapier plan costs $8,000 in year one.
- Q5 Will I get documentation? Written walkthrough and a Loom video should be standard. If a vendor can't document what they built, that's a red flag.
- Q6 What's your process before you start building? The best automation specialists do a discovery or scoping call before writing a single line of logic. If someone quotes without understanding your workflow, they're guessing.
Get a free fixed-price quote for your business. No retainers. No ongoing fees to us. You own everything we build. We'll scope it on a free 30-minute call and send you a written quote before we start.
Get Your Free Quote →