Why this comparison matters
Mindbody is the default choice most fitness studio owners land on because it is the biggest name in the space. Pike13 is less well known but has a real following among personal training studios, boutique gyms, and operators who switched away from Mindbody specifically because they found it too heavy.
The decision is not obvious. If you need discovery — a consumer marketplace where potential members can find your studio — Mindbody wins on that dimension alone. If you want a cleaner interface, faster onboarding, and better reporting without paying for features you will never use, Pike13 is worth a serious look.
What neither platform does well: the member lifecycle work that happens outside the booking window. But we will get to that.
"The studios most frustrated with Mindbody are usually not on the wrong platform — they are on the right plan for the wrong reasons. The Starter tier gets you in the door but not much else."
Quick comparison: Mindbody vs Pike13
| Feature | Mindbody | Pike13 |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing | ~$129–$599/mo depending on plan | $129–$299/mo depending on plan |
| Setup complexity | Moderate to high — significant configuration | Low to moderate — faster onboarding |
| Consumer marketplace | Mindbody app — large fitness discovery network | None — no consumer marketplace |
| Class & membership management | Deep — purpose-built for class-based studios | Strong — clean and well-structured |
| Reporting | Available, can be complex to navigate | Cleaner, more actionable out of the box |
| Marketing tools | Mindbody Marketing suite (higher tiers only) | Basic client communication tools |
| Personal training workflows | Supported, not optimized for it | Strong — built for trainer-client relationships |
| Staff management | Available across plans | Included with payroll reporting |
| Multi-location | Stronger multi-location support | Available, less robust at scale |
| AI features | Messenger[ai] AI front desk | None |
| Best for | Yoga, pilates, multi-location studios, discovery-dependent growth | Personal training, boutique gyms, operators who want simplicity |
Pricing
Both platforms start at $129/month, which makes the initial comparison feel like a wash. It is not.
Mindbody's Starter plan at $129/month is genuinely limited. The marketing automation tools that most studios actually want — lapsed member campaigns, promotional messaging, advanced reporting — require the Accelerate plan at around $279/month or higher. Many studios end up spending $279–$599/month once they realize what the base tier excludes. The higher tiers also unlock Messenger[ai], Mindbody's AI front desk feature.
Pike13 tops out at $299/month and includes its full feature set at mid-tier pricing. You are not buying your way to the useful version of the product. The ceiling is lower, but so is the floor — and for most single-location studios, the ceiling is plenty.
Pricing reality: A studio that starts on Mindbody Starter at $129/mo and upgrades to Accelerate within six months (which is common) pays $279/mo going forward — $3,348/year. Pike13's top plan is $299/mo — $3,588/year. At that point, the price difference is not the decision driver. Features are.
Mindbody — deep dive
Mindbody has been the dominant platform in fitness studio management for over two decades. Its depth in class scheduling, membership billing, waitlists, and series pass management is real. It was built for this use case and it shows.
The consumer marketplace is Mindbody's clearest differentiation. Millions of people use the Mindbody app to find and book fitness classes. If a potential member searches "yoga studio near me" on the Mindbody app, your studio can show up. That is a discovery channel that Pike13 simply does not offer.
Where Mindbody wins:
- Consumer app with a large fitness-focused user base — real discovery channel for new members, not just booking software for existing ones.
- Class scheduling depth: capacity limits, waitlists, recurring schedules, substitute teacher management, series passes, and unlimited membership tiers.
- Mindbody Marketing (Accelerate and above) for lapsed member campaigns, promotional emails, and automated re-engagement sequences.
- Messenger[ai] handles inbound texts about class schedules, pricing, and availability without requiring staff to respond manually.
- Multi-location management is more robust. If you run three studios, Mindbody's architecture handles that better than Pike13's.
- Strong integrations ecosystem — Zapier, ClassPass, and a wide API.
Where Mindbody has limitations:
- The interface has a reputation for being clunky. It is not a new complaint, and it is fair. Navigation takes time to learn, and the admin dashboard is dense.
- Reporting is available but hard to use without some training. Getting the specific numbers you want often requires building custom reports rather than relying on defaults.
- The Starter plan is underselling the platform — but the price jump to Accelerate is steep for a small studio still figuring out its membership model.
- Personal training workflows are a secondary use case. It works, but it was not designed with a trainer-client relationship as the central unit of operation.
- Marketing add-ons cost extra at lower tiers. You can buy individual campaign credits rather than getting a full suite, but the piecemeal approach adds up.
Pike13 — deep dive
Pike13 started as a platform focused on personal training and small fitness businesses. It has expanded to serve class-based studios effectively, but its DNA shows in how it handles the trainer-client relationship — session tracking, trainer scheduling, client visit history — better than Mindbody does at comparable price points.
The interface is faster to navigate. That is subjective, but it is consistent feedback from studios that have used both platforms. The reporting is also cleaner. Default dashboards surface attendance trends, membership revenue, and staff performance without requiring users to build custom report templates.
Where Pike13 wins:
- Simpler, more intuitive interface. Staff can be trained on it in a day. Mindbody typically takes longer.
- Better reporting out of the box. Attendance by class, revenue by membership type, staff utilization — the defaults are more useful without customization.
- Personal training workflows: session packages, trainer assignment, session remaining tracking, and client history are first-class features, not afterthoughts.
- Staff scheduling and payroll reporting are included at mid-tier without separate add-on costs.
- Flat, predictable pricing. You know what you are getting at each tier without worrying about add-ons unlocking core features.
- Branded client experience — clients interact through your studio's brand, not a third-party marketplace.
Where Pike13 has limitations:
- No consumer marketplace. If you rely on Mindbody app discovery for new members, Pike13 cannot replicate that. You need to generate traffic through your own marketing.
- Smaller integrations ecosystem. Mindbody has more native integrations, though Pike13 connects to common tools via Zapier and its API.
- Marketing tools are basic. There is no equivalent to Mindbody Marketing's automated campaign suite. Email and SMS communication exists, but it is not a marketing automation platform.
- Multi-location businesses with more than two or three studios may find Pike13 less capable than Mindbody for managing cross-location reporting and staff rosters.
- No AI front desk feature. Inbound inquiries still require staff to handle.
"Pike13 has a cleaner interface and better default reporting. That matters more than it sounds when your front desk staff spends 20 minutes a day fighting software instead of talking to members."
Ease of use
Mindbody is feature-rich and consequently complex. Studios regularly report that new staff take one to two weeks to feel comfortable in the admin interface. The class schedule builder, membership configuration, and reporting tools all have learning curves. Mindbody has improved its onboarding over the years, but it is still the heavier product.
Pike13 is not simple — running a fitness studio is not simple — but the interface is better organized for day-to-day operations. Checking in a client, adjusting a class roster, pulling a revenue report: these tasks are faster. For studios where the owner is also the front desk and the head instructor, that efficiency matters.
Neither platform is plug-and-play. Both require real setup time to configure membership tiers, billing cycles, class schedules, and staff permissions. If you want something lightweight and minimalist, look at scheduling-only tools like Acuity instead — though those lack the membership and billing depth that a serious fitness studio needs.
Consumer marketplace
This is the starkest difference between the two platforms, and it should drive the conversation for any studio that depends on walk-in discovery.
Mindbody's consumer app has millions of active users looking for fitness classes in their area. Being listed on Mindbody means a potential member who has never heard of your studio can find it through the app, book a trial class, and become a paying member — all without ever seeing your website. That is a real acquisition channel.
Pike13 does not have this. Your new member growth depends entirely on your own marketing: Google search, paid ads, referrals, social media, community outreach. That is fine if you already have a marketing system in place. It is a meaningful gap if you were planning to lean on platform discovery.
Worth noting: Mindbody's marketplace listing is included in the subscription, but visibility in the app depends on factors like review count, proximity, and plan tier. Paying for Mindbody does not guarantee meaningful discovery traffic. Studios in competitive markets often find they need to do their own marketing regardless of which platform they use.
Who each platform is actually for
Choose Mindbody when: Your studio is established and depends on the Mindbody consumer app for new member discovery. You run multiple locations and need centralized management. You want the Messenger[ai] front desk feature to handle inbound messages at scale. You are a large yoga or pilates studio with complex membership tiers, waitlists, and promotional campaigns that justify the Accelerate or Ultimate plan cost.
Choose Pike13 when: Your revenue model centers on personal training or small group training, and trainer-client session tracking matters. You want cleaner reporting without building custom queries. Your staff has high turnover or limited software experience, and onboarding speed matters. You are a single-location boutique gym or studio that generates new members through its own marketing, not a marketplace.
Consider neither when: You are a solo trainer or very small operation with a handful of clients. At that scale, a lighter tool — or even a combination of Acuity Scheduling and simple payment processing — may be cheaper and less overhead than either of these platforms.
The automation gap both platforms share
Both Mindbody and Pike13 handle what happens inside the booking window well enough: scheduling, confirmations, reminders, membership billing. That is the baseline.
What neither platform handles automatically: the member lifecycle work that drives retention and referrals.
A member attends their first class. Does your software send a personalized text 24 hours later asking how it went and inviting them to leave a Google review? Probably not. A member who was attending three times a week has not shown up in 30 days. Does your software automatically flag that and send a win-back message with a specific offer? Not out of the box. A member hits their 10th class milestone. Does your software trigger a referral sequence asking them to bring a friend? No.
These workflows are not exotic. They are standard retention and growth tactics that any well-run fitness studio should have in place. The problem is that both Mindbody and Pike13 treat them as manual tasks — someone on your team has to remember to look at the lapsed member list, export it, and send messages by hand.
The math on win-backs: If your studio has 200 active members and a typical 20% monthly churn, that is 40 members drifting away each month. A single automated win-back sequence that recovers 10% of those — 4 members — at $100/month average membership value is $400/month recovered, or $4,800/year. From one automated flow.
Mindbody's marketing tools on higher-tier plans get closer to this — you can set up automated campaigns for lapsed members — but the configuration requires real effort, the triggers are limited, and the member behavior data does not automatically feed into multi-channel sequences. Pike13's tools are simpler and further from this capability.
That is where Aplos AI fits. We build the automation layer that runs on top of whichever platform you choose — connecting your booking data to SMS sequences, review request flows, referral campaigns, and reporting dashboards that tie your marketing spend to actual member acquisition. No platform switch required. We extend what you already have.
Verdict
Mindbody is the right answer for studios that want consumer marketplace discovery, multi-location management, or the Messenger[ai] front desk feature — and are willing to pay for it and deal with a heavier interface. For yoga studios and pilates studios where Mindbody's consumer app is a real acquisition channel, the platform still earns its price.
Pike13 wins for studios that prioritize ease of use, personal training workflows, and cleaner reporting — and that generate new members through their own marketing rather than a third-party app. It is a more focused product at a more contained price.
The honest answer for most single-location boutique fitness studios: try Pike13 first if you do not have an existing Mindbody presence. The interface advantage and reporting quality are real day-to-day benefits. If you later need the consumer marketplace or multi-location tools, Mindbody will still be there.
Either way, neither platform automates your retention and growth work automatically. That requires a separate layer.
No automated win-back for members who go quiet? No review requests after a first class? We map your current member lifecycle in a free audit and show exactly which automated sequences would have the most impact for your studio — on top of Mindbody, Pike13, or whatever you already run.
Get a Free Automation Audit →